Currently Empty: $0.00
Driving under the influence is one of the leading causes of road accidents and fatalities in Australia. To prevent drink driving, strict laws across the country make it mandatory for drivers to comply with random breath testing when asked by law enforcement. But what happens if you refuse a breath test? Is it worth the risk? This article explores the legal implications, focusing on penalties and how refusal impacts different states and territories.
What Happens When You Refuse a Breath Test?
By law, every state in Australia requires drivers to undergo breath testing when requested by police. Refusing a breathalyser test or failing to provide an adequate breath sample is considered a serious offence. The consequences include fines, disqualification of your driving licence, and even imprisonment. Each state has its specific legal provisions, but the underlying message is clear—refusal is not taken lightly.
Police Powers and Breath Tests
Police officers are empowered to stop any vehicle for breath testing if they suspect a driver of being under the influence or after an accident. They have the authority to direct how the test is to be conducted. Failing to comply with these directions, such as not providing a sufficient breath sample or refusing altogether, is a punishable offence.
Importantly, refusal to comply with a breathalyser test carries penalties that are often more severe than those for lower-range drink-driving itself.
Refusing a Breath Test in South Australia
South Australia enforces strict rules under the Road Traffic Act 1961. It is an offence to refuse or fail to provide a breath sample when required by a police officer. The penalties are severe:
- First Offence
- Fine ranging between $1,100 and $1,600
- Mandatory licence disqualification for a minimum of 12 months
- Subsequent Offence
- Fine between $1,900 and $2,900
- Licence disqualification for at least 3 years
If the incident is deemed “trifling” (a situation of low seriousness), the court may order a lesser disqualification period of at least one month.
Trifling Offences
To have a refusal categorised as a trifling offence, you will need strong evidence. This could include medical reports stating legitimate reasons for being unable to provide a breath sample.
National Overview of the Legal Obligation to Comply
Breath Tests Across Australia
While breathalyser laws vary slightly across states, the principle remains the same: refusal to take the test leads to significant legal implications. Here’s how penalties breakdown in other states:
- New South Wales (NSW): Breach of Road Transport Act 2013 may result in a $3,300 fine for first refusal and up to $5,500 for repeated offences, along with licence disqualification of up to three years.
- Victoria: Penalties include a fine and immediate licence suspension, with imprisonment possible for repeat offenders.
- Northern Territory (NT): Refusing to stop for a breath test can attract hefty fines of up to $29,800 and one year of imprisonment.
Refusing a Blood Test or Drug Screening
If you are unable or refuse to provide a breath sample, police may request an oral fluid analysis or blood test. Refusal to comply is another offence, and courts view it as seriously as refusal of a breathalyser test. Penalties often mirror those for high-range drink driving.
Some states allow medical professionals to take blood samples as an alternative, especially in cases where a driver feels physically incapable of providing a sufficient breath sample.
Consequences of Refusal
Fines and Licence Disqualification
Penalties for failing to comply include steep fines and losing your driving privileges for an extended period. Licence suspension can range from six months to several years. The penalties increase significantly for repeat offenders or if the case is severe.
Criminal Record
Refusing a breathalyser test often results in a criminal record, which can lead to long-term complications such as difficulty finding employment, inability to travel internationally, and higher car insurance premiums.
Impact on Insurance
A refusal conviction can cause car insurance providers to deny coverage or impose significantly higher premiums. You may face challenges in finding affordable insurance.
Imprisonment
While imprisonment is typically reserved for repeat offences, failing to provide a breath test under certain conditions can lead to a jail sentence, which depends on state-specific laws and the severity of the situation.
When Can You Decline a Breath Test?
There are very few lawful defences for refusing a breath test or breathalyser. One such scenario involves having a documented medical condition that makes it impossible to perform the test. However, the burden of proof falls on you to provide evidence, including:
- A valid medical report explaining why it was impossible to perform the test.
- Blood test results showing you were not over the legal alcohol limit.
Without any substantial defence, declining the breath test will almost always carry penalties more severe than complying.
Key Takeaways for Drivers
Refusing a breathalyser test carries heavy legal and financial implications, often far outweighing those for cooperating. It’s important to understand your rights but also your obligations under Australian law. Here’s what you need to remember:
- Always comply: Refusal or non-compliance makes penalties unavoidable.
- Know the penalties: Penalties differ across states but universally include fines, licence disqualifications, and potentially imprisonment.
- Medical defences require proof: A simple claim isn’t sufficient; you need substantial documentation.
If you find yourself facing charges, consult a legal expert familiar with local laws to ensure proper representation in court.
Protect Yourself and Others
The By complying with the law, you help keep yourself and others safe on the road. Understanding your legal obligations and the consequences of refusing can save you from unnecessary penalties and significant stress.
Source
